Should You Sell or Lease Your Commercial Building?

Moving your business, retiring, or just tired of managing a building? Here's how to think through whether to sell it or keep it as a rental.

I talk with a lot of owners in Richmond and the surrounding area who are at a crossroads with a building. Maybe the business is relocating or closing, maybe they're approaching retirement, or maybe they've just received an unsolicited offer. The question is the same: should I sell it, or lease it out and keep it?

There's no universal answer, but there is a good way to work through it.

Start with your goals

Do you need the cash for something else, like a new location, retirement or another investment? Do you want ongoing income, and are you comfortable being a landlord? How long do you want to own real estate, and what's your plan for the property in your estate? How much risk are you comfortable carrying if a tenant leaves?

The case for selling

Selling turns equity into cash you can use elsewhere. It ends maintenance, tenant issues, vacancies and capital repairs. It's a clean exit if the building needs major work you don't want to fund, and it lets you take advantage of strong demand if buyers are active for your property type.

The case for leasing

Leasing gives you ongoing income while you keep ownership, along with potential long-term appreciation and loan paydown. You keep the flexibility to sell later, possibly with a tenant in place that makes the property more valuable to investors. Some owners use a lease as a bridge while they decide what's next.

Run the numbers both ways

Hypothetical example: a simplified comparison

Estimated sale price: $600,000

Less estimated selling costs and loan payoff: -$190,000

Net proceeds if sold: $410,000

Projected annual rent if leased: $54,000

Less owner-paid expenses and reserves: -$14,000

Projected NOI if leased: $40,000

NOI as a return on $410,000 of equity: about 9.8%

Hypothetical figures for illustration only. Actual proceeds, rents, expenses and taxes depend on your property and situation.

That last line is the real question: is the income from keeping the building a good return on the equity you could otherwise take out? Compare it to what you'd realistically do with the cash, and factor in the time, risk and vacancy that come with being a landlord.

Don't skip the tax conversation

Selling a long-held commercial building can trigger capital gains and depreciation recapture. Some owners use a 1031 exchange to defer taxes by reinvesting in other real estate. Leasing has its own tax implications. I'm not a CPA or tax attorney, and this is exactly where your tax advisor should be involved before you decide.

Questions I'd ask about your building

What would it realistically sell for today, and what would it realistically rent for? How long would it likely take to find a qualified buyer or tenant? What improvements would a tenant expect, and who pays for them? Is there a buyer pool for this property with a tenant in place? What major repairs are coming in the next five years?

If you're weighing this decision, I'm happy to put together both sides: a realistic value if you sell and a realistic lease scenario if you hold, so you can compare them with your accountant. Call or text Shane at 859-229-1524, or request a consultation on the Contact page.

This article is general information, not tax, legal, financing or investment advice. Examples are hypothetical. Consult your CPA, attorney and lender about your specific situation.

Previous
Previous

Understanding Cap Rates When Buying Commercial Property

Next
Next

How Much Is My Commercial Property Worth in Richmond, KY?