Understanding Cap Rates When Buying Commercial Property

The cap rate is the first number most investors look at. It's useful, but only if you understand what it does and doesn't tell you.

If you've looked at a commercial listing, you've probably seen a cap rate in the first line of the description. It's the shorthand the industry uses to compare investment properties. As an investor myself, it's one of the first numbers I look at, and one of the first numbers I question.

What a cap rate is

The capitalization rate is a property's net operating income divided by its price. In plain terms, it's the annual return the property would produce if you paid cash, before financing and taxes.

Hypothetical example: the basic math

Purchase price: $800,000

Gross rent: $84,000

Operating expenses: -$20,000

Net operating income (NOI): $64,000

Cap rate (NOI / price): 8.0%

Illustrative numbers only. Not a quote of current market cap rates in Richmond or Central Kentucky.

What a higher or lower cap rate means

A higher cap rate means more income for every dollar of price. That usually comes with more perceived risk: an older building, shorter leases, a weaker tenant or a less proven location. A lower cap rate usually means the market sees the income as safer and more durable, like a long-term lease to a national tenant.

Neither is automatically good or bad. The question is whether the return fits the risk you're taking.

Where cap rates can mislead you

The NOI might be optimistic. Some listings use projected rents or leave out expenses like management, reserves for replacements, or vacancy. Always rebuild the NOI yourself from actual numbers.

It's a snapshot. A cap rate reflects one year of income. It says nothing about a lease that expires in eight months or a roof that needs replacing next year.

It ignores financing. Most buyers use debt, and the cap rate doesn't show what your actual cash return will be after loan payments.

It ignores growth. Two properties at the same cap rate can have very different futures if one has below-market rents and the other has rents at their peak.

Cap rate vs. cash-on-cash return

Once financing is involved, I look at cash-on-cash return: the annual cash flow after debt service divided by the cash you actually invested.

Hypothetical example: same property, with a loan

Down payment (25%): $200,000

Annual loan payments (hypothetical terms): -$46,000

Cash flow after debt service ($64,000 - $46,000): $18,000

Cash-on-cash return ($18,000 / $200,000): 9.0%

Debt service coverage ratio ($64,000 / $46,000): 1.39x

Hypothetical loan terms for illustration only. Your actual rate, term and lender requirements will change these results; confirm financing with your lender.

Lenders pay close attention to that last number, the debt service coverage ratio. Many commercial lenders want to see NOI comfortably above the loan payment, often around 1.25 times or more, though requirements vary.

How I use cap rates when evaluating a deal

I rebuild the NOI from the actual rent roll and expense history; add realistic vacancy, management and reserves even if the seller didn't; compare the cap rate to recent sales of similar properties, not just to other listings; run the numbers with financing to see the real cash return; and look at what happens when the biggest lease expires.

A cap rate is a starting point, not a verdict. The real work is understanding the income behind it.

Want to run the numbers on your next deal? Call or text Shane at 859-229-1524, or request a consultation on the Contact page.

This article is general information, not tax, legal, financing or investment advice. Examples are hypothetical. Consult your CPA, attorney and lender about your specific situation.

Next
Next

Should You Sell or Lease Your Commercial Building?